First of all, if you're here to talk about anything less than serious, "you look so tired!," puffy purple dark circles, then just GTFO right now because that's what we're talking about.

Let's talk concealer

Okay then. (Sorry for the harsh so early in the morning, but this is serious business).

I need a new concealer for my undereye circles. Here are the ones I've tried recently and my issues with them:

LANCôME EFFACERNES in Porcelaine I - some lovely lady here recommended this and I thought it would be a holy grail. Well, I bought it over the weekend and I don't like it. It's too sheer or something. For reference, these are my eyes right now with the concealer on:

Let's talk concealer

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer in Vanilla - it's pretty decent, but the formula is a bit thin and it creases. Good color, though.

Benefit Erase Paste in Fair - it never fully settles in (stays kind of thick and gooey) and I don't love the color; even fair is a bit dark.

Jezzies - what are your recommendations for where to turn next? Someone at one point recommended Clé de Peau Beauté, which is not off the table entirely if I must, but I'd really like to avoid spending $70 on concealer if possible.